Fluent in English, Spanish & Italian | 888-882-9243

call us toll free: 888-8TAXAID

Monthly Archives: May 2020

DC Finds That FBAR Penalty Not Violate 8th Amendment & Imposed a Penalty of $12.9M Based Upon FMV on June 30

On September 4, 2019 we posted FBAR Consent to Extend Statute Held Valid!, we discussed that In United States v. Schwarzbaum (S.D. Fla. No. 18-cv-81147) a federal district court rejected an individual's claims that FBAR penalties assessed against him should be set aside because they were assessed after the limitations period expired.

Now in U.S. v. Isac Schwarzbaum, case number 9:18-cv-81147, in the US District Court for the Southern District of Florida, the Court has determined that Schwarzbaum, will pay the IRS a $12.9 million penalty for failing to file reports on his foreign bank accounts, a federal court ordered after having determined that the agency erred when it calculated the penalty at $800,000 more.

The court concluded that the penalty assessed by the government did not conform to statutory requirements because rather than utilizing 50% of the balance in each account at the time of the violation, which was the deadline to file the FBAR or June 30 of each year, the government used the highest aggregate balance in each of the accounts for each year as reported by Taxpayer on a penalty calculation worksheet provided in connection with his OVDI disclosures.

As a result, the court concluded:

  1. That the IRS used the incorrect base amounts to calculate the FBAR penalties,
  2. It rejected that the IRS’s methodology in calculating the penalty was harmless error and
  3. The court also concluded that an FBAR penalty does not fall within the purview of the Eighth Amendment’s excessive fines provision.






The Internal Revenue Service cannot use estimates of what was in Isac Schwarzbaum's foreign accounts to calculate his penalty, set by federal tax law at the greater of $100,000 or half the account, U.S. District Court Judge Beth Bloom said in a decision issued on May 18, 2020. It must have the actual amounts or use the $100,000 figure, she said. 

Schwarzbaum Had Faced A $13.7 Million Tax Penalty Before Judge Bloom Determined That The Internal Revenue Service Had Erroneously Calculated It And She Determined
The Correct Penalty To Be $12.9 Million.

Each willful violation has a penalty of $100,000 or half the amount in a foreign account on the date of the violation, Judge Bloom said in her March opinion, citing Section 5321, Title 31 of the U.S. Code. 31 U.S.C. 5321 The IRS used the highest aggregate balance in the accounts, not the amount on June 30, she said.  
The statute at issue in this case states as follows:

[. . .]

(D) Amount.—The amount determined under this subparagraph is—

[. . .]
  • (ii) in the case of a violation involving a failure to report the existence of an account or any identifying information required to be provided with respect to an account, the balance in the account at the time of the violation.
The IRS was unable to independently determine the June 30 balance in several of Schwarzbaum's accounts, according to court documents. In a supplemental brief filed in April, the agency asked Judge Bloom to use its estimates, arguing they were the best information available. Otherwise, taxpayers might be encouraged to withhold balance information, the IRS said.

Judge Bloom rejected the agency's arguments in the May 18, 2020 ruling, saying it should have obtained the balance information before it assessed penalties. Using the $100,000 figure where the balances were estimated, she added half of the June 30 account balances, calculating the penalty amount at $12.9 million.

Schwarzbaum didn't dispute that he had a number of foreign bank accounts, or that he failed to timely file the reports from 2006 through 2009, according to court documents. He argued he should not be penalized for willingly failing to file because he received poor advice from a number of financial advisers and filed after discovering the error.

The IRS had argued Schwarzbaum, by signing his tax returns, implicitly reviewed them and knew he failed to file. The judge disagreed in the March opinion, pointing out that by that logic, every failure to file would be willful because every return must be signed.

Turning to each year in question in the March opinion, Judge Bloom found:

 

  • Schwarzbaum did not willfully fail to file his 2006 report. He relied on an accountant to prepare it and followed the accountant's advice that no tax was due, she said.
  • However, Schwarzbaum personally filed the 2007 through 2009 returns, she said, and should have known by 2007 how to properly disclose the accounts.
     

    Have Undeclared Income from an Offshore Account?  

     
    Want to Know Which OVDP Program is Right for You?
     
     

     
    Contact the Tax Lawyers at 
    Marini& Associates, P.A. 
     
     
    for a FREE Tax Consultation
    Toll Free at 888-8TaxAid (888) 882-9243


     


 
 Sources:

Law360

 

Read more at: Tax Times blog

IRS Provides Updates on Compliance, Exam Activities Through July 15

In two Tax Tips, the IRS has provided an updates on its suspended compliance and examination activities through the July 15, 2020 filing and payment deadline.

On March 25, 2020, the IRS announced its People First Initiative and, as part of this initiative, suspended certain compliance and examination activities due to the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak. See IRS suspends certain compliance programs due to COVID-19 (03/26/2020).
In Tax Tip 2020-56, the IRS has provided the following updates on its suspended compliance activities through the July 15, 2020 filing and payment deadline:  
  • Existing installment agreements. Payments due under an existing installment agreement between April 1 and July 15, 2020 are delayed until July 15, 2020. Those taxpayers currently unable to meet the terms of an existing Installment Payment Agreement may skip payments during this period with no default. By law, interest will continue to accumulate on any unpaid balances.
  • New installment agreements. Taxpayers who can't pay all their federal taxes can establish an installment agreement using the IRS's online application.
  • Pending Offer in Compromise (OIC) applications. Taxpayers have until July 15, 2020, to provide additional information for a pending OIC. The IRS generally won't close any pending OIC request before July 15 without the taxpayer's consent.
  • OIC payments. Taxpayers can delay all payments on accepted OICs until July 15, 2020. Interest may accrue, and missed payments are due when the suspension period ends. Taxpayers can call the number on their OIC acceptance letter if they have any questions about their OIC payments.
  • No OIC default for delinquent return filings. The IRS will not default an OIC for taxpayers who are delinquent in filing their tax return for 2018. However, they should file any delinquent 2018 return and their 2019 return by July 15, 2020.
  • 2016 refund deadline. The deadline to get refunds on 2016 tax returns is July 15, 2020. 
  • Field collection activities. The IRS has stopped field revenue officer enforcement actions, such as liens and levies. Revenue officers will continue to pursue high-income non-filers and perform "other similar activities" where necessary.
  • Automated liens and levies. The IRS has delayed issuing new automated and systemic liens and levies. Taxpayers experiencing a hardship due to a levy should reach out to their assigned IRS contact.
  • Certifications to the State Department. IRS has delayed new certifications of taxpayers who are considered seriously delinquent. This affects a person's ability to receive a new or renewed passport. Existing certifications will remain in place unless their tax situation changes.
  • Private debt collection. The IRS will not forward new delinquent accounts to private collection agencies until after July 15, 2020.
In Tax Tip 2020-57, the IRS has provided the following updates on its examination and audit activities through July 15, 2020: 
  • Field, office and correspondence audits. Generally, the IRS won't start new field, office or correspondence audits before July 15, 2020. However, the IRS may start new audits if needed to preserve the limitations period. 
  • In-person meetings for current field and office audits are still on hold but, when possible, examiners continue to work their cases remotely. 
  • The IRS may move forward with an audit when (1) its in the best interest of both parties, and (2) appropriate representatives of both parties are available. 
  • Earned income tax credit (EITC) and wage verification reviews.  Taxpayers have until July 15, 2020, to respond to any IRS correspondence asking them to verify (1) that they qualify for the earned income tax credit, or (2) their income. These taxpayers should submit all the requested information as soon as possible. The IRS won't deny the EITC for a failure to provide information until July 15, 2020.
  • Limitations periods.  If a limitations period is about to expire, the IRS encourages taxpayers to cooperate in extending that limitations period. If a taxpayer fails to cooperate in extending the limitations period, the IRS will take any actions necessary to protect the interests of the government. 
The IRS previously stated, in IR 2020-59, when a statutory period is not set to expire during 2020, the IRS is unlikely to ask the taxpayer to extend that period before July 15, 2020.

Have an IRS Tax Problem?
 
 
Contact the Tax Lawyers at
Marini & Associates, P.A.   
for a FREE Tax Consultation contact us at:
Toll Free at 888-8TaxAid (888) 882-9243

 

Read more at: Tax Times blog

IRS Is Back! … They Are Bring Back Workers In 3 States Starting June 1

On May 20, 2020 we posted IRS Is Asking More Workers To Return To Work Voluntarily Amid The Pandemic, where we discussed that The Internal Revenue Service is recalling about 46,000 of its employees furloughed by the government shutdown, nearly 60 percent of its workforce, to handle tax returns and pay out refunds. The employees won't be paid during the shutdown and the IRS is asking more employees to volunteer to return to work on site with incentive pay as the agency begins to reopen offices that were closed because of the COVID-19 pandemic, the union representing agency employees said.

 
Now according to Law360, the IRS plans to order employees in Kentucky, Texas and Utah who can't telework to return to their worksites starting June 1, Commissioner Chuck Rettig told workers May 19, 2020, saying the agency would keep pursuing employee safety amid the COVID-19 pandemic.
 

Rettig delivered the news in an email to agency workers. Tony Reardon, national president of the National Treasury Employees Union, which represents IRS workers, said in a statement that according to the agency, there are about 20,000 IRS employees in the three states. About 9,000 will continue to telework, subjecting 11,000 to the recall, Reardon said.
 
Reardon said the IRS has informed the union that agency "posts of duty" in those states have been thoroughly disinfected, a comprehensive cleaning schedule is in place and there are sufficient supplies of personal protective equipment for workers to help prevent the spread of COVID-19, the respiratory disease caused by the novel coronavirus.
 
The union leader said the health and safety of returning workers is a priority for the union, which is why it will continue urging the IRS to provide the returning employees with tests and basic medical screenings.
 

"The IRS Made Clear That After An Initial Call For Volunteers In Certain IRS Divisions To Return To Work, Mandatory Callbacks Were Likely," Reardon Said.
 

"Such advance notice, however, does not alleviate the anxiety of the IRS frontline employees, who, just like most Americans, recognize that the health crisis has not fully subsided and are worried about protecting themselves and their families."

The directive for some employees to return follows agency workers voluntarily coming back. Earlier this month, Reardon said the union supported an IRS call for additional employees to volunteer to return, but said they needed to feel safe doing so, particularly after a Kansas City, Missouri, worker contracted COVID-19.

Rettig said in his email that over the next several weeks, the agency will continue asking employees whose work isn't portable to return to their posts of duty.

 

The IRS Is Aware Of Growing Taxpayer Needs And
An Expanding Backlog Of Work At Its Office
And Campus Locations, He Said.
 



Employees who are sick shouldn't come in and may have to provide documentation if sick leave exceeds three consecutive workdays, Rettig said in the email.

Workers who are in high-risk populations as defined by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention may ask for weather and safety leave if they can't telework, he said.

 


Have an IRS Tax Problem?
 
 
Contact the Tax Lawyers at
Marini & Associates, P.A.   

for a FREE Tax Consultation contact us at:
Toll Free at 888-8TaxAid (888) 882-9243



Read more at: Tax Times blog

IRS Is Asking More Workers To Return To Work Voluntarily Amid The Pandemic

 On April 29, 2020 we posted They're Back! - That is Right the IRS Has Begun to Recall Employees,

where we discussed that The Internal Revenue Service is recalling about 46,000 of its employees furloughed by the government shutdown, nearly 60 percent of its workforce, to handle tax returns and pay out refunds. The employees won't be paid during the shutdown.
 
That now the IRS is asking more workers to return to work voluntarily amid the pandemic. According to Law360, The IRS is asking more employees to volunteer to return to work on site with incentive pay as the agency begins to reopen offices that were closed because of the COVID-19 pandemic, the union representing agency employees said Thursday.
 

The National Treasury Employees' Union Supports The Internal Revenue Service's Call For Additional Employees To Volunteer To Return To Work During The Pandemic, NTEU President Tony Reardon Said In A Statement.

 

Nevertheless, he added, they should feel safe enough to do so, especially after an agency employee contracted the illness in Kansas City IRS employees who volunteer to return to work should have sufficient personal protective equipment such as masks and hand sanitizer readily available, and additional steps should be taken to clean office spaces, Reardon said.
 
"We will continue to work with the IRS to find the right balance between delivering a tax-filing season and keeping federal employees safe," Reardon said.
 

He Added That The Union Would Continue To Urge The Agency To Extend The Filing Deadline Even Further,
From July 15 To Oct. 15. 

 
The IRS didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. Reardon said that ensuring employees' safety is even more critical after an IRS employee in Kansas City last week contracted COVID-19, the respiratory disease caused by the novel coronavirus.
 
According to a Facebook post by the local NTEU chapter in Kansas City, the IRS campus there will be closed until May 12 to ensure the space is properly cleaned, and then employees will be able to return on a limited basis.
 
Last week, the IRS told the NTEU it had secured enough face masks for agency employees who volunteered to return to work. The agency also reported that there are few enough returning workers that they can comply with physical distancing standards, Reardon said.
 
Reardon previously said that state and local orders requiring people to stay home should be lifted and that other conditions should be met before federal employees returned to their offices.
 
The union's conditions for bringing back workers also included proof of thorough cleaning of sites, adequate supplies of sanitizers and disinfectants, a policy of voluntary maximum telework, work spaces that provide for physical distancing, procedures for taking employees' temperatures before they enter buildings and permitting and providing the use of cloth face coverings.
 
In March, the IRS extended the April tax filing deadline to July 15 to account for hardships caused by the coronavirus pandemic. The agency also took steps in March to temporarily suspend some tax enforcement efforts and generally not begin new audits or collection efforts until July 15.
 
Additionally, the IRS shuttered all its service centers and Taxpayer Assistance Centers and is holding mail. The IRS has also directed much of its workforce to telework and suspended some enforcement actions.
 
HAVE AN IRS TAX PROBLEM?


Contact the Tax Lawyers at
Marini & Associates, P.A.   
for a FREE Tax Consultation contact us at:
Toll Free at 888-8TaxAid (888) 882-924


Read more at: Tax Times blog

Live Help